Warning: This article contains spoilers for One Piece issue #1164.
The saying 'History is recorded by the winners' serves as a central theme that One Piece author Eiichiro Oda has long integrated into the narrative. Legends frequently fail to capture the complete truth, including the most influential characters in this world's intricate past. Oden was no silly performer prancing through the roads of Wano Country; he acted out of duty and conviction. Bartholomew Kuma was not a ruthless antagonist who tore apart the Straw Hats, either; he was helping them. Likewise, the Davy Jones legend meant more than a pirate's game in pursuit of emblems and followers.
In installment #1164 of the manga, we witness the culmination of this idea. The whole Divine Isle narrative acts as a cautionary tale, instructing audiences not to evaluate the individuals too hastily.
Legends frequently do not capture the complete truth, including the most influential figures.
One Piece's most recent flashback, detailing the Divine Isle incident, stands as one of the story's finest storylines to date. Apart from the thrill of seeing legends in their prime, it's compelling to observe them prior to when they became symbols — when their reputation had yet to outgrow their human nature. The past, as written by the World Government and recounted through hearsay tales, shaped our perception of individuals like Roger, Xebec, and even Monkey D. Garp. But both the government's accounts and the stories of those who knew them turn out to be unreliable, revealing only fragments of who these individuals really were.
The Man Prior to the Myth
The future Pirate King may have been driven by mission and the bold spirit that ignited a new age of piracy, but prior to he was known as the King of the Pirates, he was a young man ruled by passion and the desire to explore. When people speak of his myth, they usually mean his second voyage, the epic expedition in search of the Road Poneglyphs that lead to Laugh Tale. Yet not much is known about his first journey, the one that molded him before fame discovered him.
At that time, Gol D. Roger was largely unaware of the globe's secret history. His love for Shakky guided him to the Divine Isle, where he discovered the Global Authority's darkest realities: the genocidal "games," the monstrous appearances of the Gorosei, and even the existence of the planet's unseen sovereign, the mysterious leader. We haven't seen Roger's reflections about all that's happening in the Divine Isle, but maybe finding the son of a God's Knight on his vessel will make him realize his role in the world and seek the truth he caught a glimpse of from Rocks D. Xebec's situation.
The Truth About The Infamous Captain
Before this recollection, what we knew of Xebec came almost entirely from Sengoku's account, both to the viewers and to new Navy recruits. He depicted Xebec as a despicable, power-hungry man bent on global control, someone so threatening that Gol D. Roger and Garp had to join forces to overcome him. But as it transpires, the strategist wasn't even there at God Valley; he was only repeating the Global Authority's approved version of events, the very narrative the sovereign authorized to conceal the truth about Rocks D. Xebec and the event itself.
In truth, Rocks D. Xebec, whose true name was Davy D. Xebec, was a ethical man who aimed to topple Imu and dismantle the decadent World Government. We are unsure if he was motivated by ambition, revenge for his clan, or a desire for fairness, but when he found out the regime's plan to eliminate the land where his family lived, he abandoned his dreams of domination to rescue them.
This love for his family became his downfall. After confronting the sovereign, he lost his will and liberty, turning into a marionette enslaved to their authority. Now, with what little consciousness is left, he begs with Roger and Garp to end his life — believing that dying would be a kindness in contrast to the living hell he suffers. The truth of Rocks D. Xebec is thus very different from the tale told by Sengoku, and the comic presents him in a positive light during the Divine Isle incidents.
Is He Still Alive Today?
But did Rocks actually meet his end? An intriguing theory is that he is even now a servant to Imu in the present day, acting as the scarred individual, keeping the World Government's last ancient stone in constant transit to keep the ultimate treasure from being found.
Garp's Secret Rebellion
Another key figure of the God Valley event is Garp, who has endured backlash from followers for years for standing by as Akainu killed Ace. That sentiment only grew more intense after the timeskip, when he endangered all to rescue the young Marine at Hachinosu, causing many to wonder why he couldn't do the same for his biological grandchild. Similar questions have now resurfaced with the Divine Isle recollection: how can Garp serve the Navy, knowing the World Government treats genocide and enslavement as sport for the upper class?
The truth reveals something distinct. The moment Monkey D. Garp witnessed the Elders' monstrous shapes, he attacked without hesitation. His alliance with Gol D. Roger was not meant to vanquish some evil Xebec, but a bold act of rebellion, an attempt to stop Imu, who was using Rocks D. Xebec as a tool to wipe out everyone in God Valley, even apparently, even the World Nobles themselves. This incident is probably the cause Monkey D. Garp despises the World Nobles in the current era and why he not once wanted to be elevated to Fleet Admiral, reporting directly to them.
The Past's Unreliable Narrators
Even though the readers are seeing the God Valley incident through a flashback recounted by Loki, including viewpoints and occurrences he clearly was absent for, I think we can treat this account as entirely accurate. The series may provide an reason in the future, maybe connected to the giant's yet unknown paramecia ability. Still, the God Valley incident perfectly embodies the notion that history is written by the victors. This attitude is {